Cheap Electricity Import from Russia may Turn into a Myth
2009-10-31
As Lithuania is intensively resolving issues of energy sector that will be likely to occur after the shutdown of Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant, it is more and more likely to hear about urges to purchase electric energy from Russia, as if it is the cheapest energy source and, in addition, Russia has as much of it as it is required.
Russian aim is the Lithuanian market
Recently, the Russian daily Komersant published information that a country that desires to augment the extent of its export is obliged to construct new power plants because the current capacities are too few. One of the projects, which would lead to most rapid implementation, would be the new gas-fired block of Khabarovsk Heat and Power Plant with the capacity reaching 400-500 megawatts. Moreover, statistics of electricity prices were announced that demonstrate that after conquering foreign markets the Russians dump the prices.
Pursuant to the data of the newspaper, price of megawatt-hour of electricity supplied to China equals around 82 litas, whereas the average price in the market of Russian Ural zone is around 125 litas. Please be reminded that the average electricity price in the European part of Russia is even higher, i.e. an average of 155 litas per megawatt-hour. Moreover, price of electric energy in Russia rises by around 10 % on an annual basis.
During stable operation of Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant, price of electricity during the Lithuanian auction would reach only 70 litas per megawatt-hour. How the price changes after the shutdown of Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant may be predicted by considering the Lithuanian auction price for June of this year. At that time Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant was not running temporarily due to planned repair works. Price of electric power rocketed up to 180 litas per megawatt-hour.
Conclusion of such price statistics is more than telling: it is feasible that Russia will be also likely to dump prices seeking for the conclusion of long-term agreements for electricity supply with Lithuania. Moreover, Russians will expand the capacity of their energy production so that the country would be likely to gain benefit from electricity export to a greater extent. Russian power will reach Lithuania too, which from January will have no producer of cheap electric power. However, the cheap lure of electricity may cost a lot to the country in the future.
In the given context it was weird to hear one month ago the statement of the President Dalia Grybauskaitė that Lithuania could do without a new combined heat and power plant in Kaunas that should be constructed after four years. Modern combined heat and power plants is one of the cheapest and most efficient sources for energy (both heat and electricity) generation.
Worthless to rely on import
“As it plans the future of its energy sector, Lithuania may not rely on the Russian sources of energy. Import from Russia caused troubles to Finland. In winter of 2005-2006 export of the Russian electric power was limited to Finland. It is predicted that around 2016 Russia will be forced to limit the consumption of electric energy because the recent construction works of new power plants are not carried out at considerable rapidness, whereas the industry of the country shows huge potential for its growth”, said Anzelmas Bačauskas, Associate Professor at Kaunas University of Technology.
Former manager of Lietuvos energija stressed that in case our country only bought electricity from elsewhere instead of generating it by itself, country’s power plants would be likely to go bankrupt: “It may happen that we will not have where to buy electric power from and in such a case we would need to bring our power plants into operation, whereas they would be “dead”. Market of energy sector is especially dynamic and situation may change within one year. What today seems economically beneficial it may be useless after half a year”.
Except for Russia, Latvia may also supply electricity to Lithuania. It may export to us electric energy during the spring and autumn seasons when there are tides and hydro power plants generate a lot of surplus energy. Estonia and Belarus will hardly compete with unduly cheap Russian electric power. Company Energijos realizacijos centras, representing the interests of the Russian energy company Inter RAO JES, will remain the major importer of the Russian energy.
Inefficient production
Electricity Market Development Plan for Lithuania, approved by the Government this summer, establishes gradual shift of the entire national electric energy economy to the free electricity trading market. From 2015 all the Lithuanian electricity consumers will be free to choose electricity supplier. This would be an ideal optimistic option. In practice, existence of real competition in the market requires electricity connections with Poland and Sweden. Energy specialists predict that before that moment the market will have a Lithuanian power plant generating very expensive electric power, heat and power plants, which are capable of meeting 15-18 % of the national demand, and several foreign investors.
Mr Bačkauskas stated that the Lithuanian power plant in Elektrėnai would make the major balance for the dumping of imported electricity prices. Thus, it is essential that this producer generated enough electric power to hold down. Even though the equipment of the power plant is out of date, they are still running.
Ministry of Energy plans that from the coming year not less than 75 % of electricity in Elektrėnai will be generated by making use of fuel oil, which is considered as an alternative to gas. However, presently a new block of the power plant is being constructed in Elektrėnai that would use gas as fuel. It is estimated that the new block will use less fuel by 30 %.
According to Vladas Paškevičius, the President of the Lithuanian Electricity Association, after the shutdown of Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant, supply of electric energy will exceed the demand because, apart from the producers, it will be the merit of import from Russia, Belarus, Estonia and Ukraine too. This will bring no changes in the extent of production of the thermal power plants because these power plants are running according to the schedule. However, electricity quantity, generated in Elektrėnai, will depend on them.
“Combined heat and power plants are beneficial when it is necessary to consider efficient use of fuel for the production of electricity and heat. Such power plants in Lithuania allow paying less for heating to Vilnius and Kaunas residents”, spoke the energy expert Mr Bačauskas about the advantages of combined heat and power plants.
Cheap heat
There is a thermal power plant in Kaunas too. After several years it will be replaced by a new modern combined heat and power plant. A billion-worth project will be implemented by the company Kauno elektrinė.
Head of Kauno elektrinė Rimandas Stonys is sure that producer within the boundaries of the country is safer than import and that is why local producers should be stimulated.
“Currently, combined heat and power technology is the most modern technology, when electricity and heat are generated simultaneously. The State should promote its own production. However, energy import tax is much lower than that of the export. It would be desirable to welcome greater attention and support from our public institutions. After all, the project is socially sensible and important not only to Kaunas, but to Lithuania too. After the construction of a new power plant heat would become cheaper to Kaunas residents”, said Mr Stonys.
According to him, once Ignalina Nuclear Power Plant is closed the problem would not relate to the supply of electricity, but its price instead. Quantity of electricity will be greater than it is needed at the moment. Thus, all producers and importers will inevitably start competing with each other.
“Price of electricity, generated at Elektrėnai power plant that runs in condensing regime, cannot compete with that of the combined heat and power plants. It is required to ensure stability of electric energy system, whereas the quantity of electricity that may be produced is an arguable issue. We do not oppose other participants of electricity market and believe that all of us may be equivalent competitors”, stressed Mr Stonys.
© Kauno diena
Other articles